Review: 'Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood'
Recently, I tried to explain to a housemate why I liked the anime Fullmetal Alchemist so much. After unsuccessfully trying to convince her and resorting to the 'it's good, just trust me' approach, I was eventually able to form an argument that made some sense:
"Fullmetal Alchemist has the ability to make you both laugh and cry, even during the same episode."
I don't tend to watch mainstream anime - my taste are inclined towards the more obscure shows - but there was always something about FMA that drew me in and kept me engaged, more so than a lot of the American drama I watch. And for me, the main reason for that is the character driven plot, and that it never takes itself too seriously. Right from the start the show is telling a story, one with as many twists and turns as a good novel, and it continues to pull the viewer along (willingly or not), even through the more comedic episodes, with various instances of plot development (like Armstrong slipping that letter into Havoc's jacket in 'The Flame Alchemist & The Mystery of Warehouse 13'). Despite only having access to the first 7 volumes of the manga, the studio managed to create a story that really worked.
Besides, I'm just a sucker for character development! =D
So when I heard that the studio was producing a new anime more closely based on the original manga (it's been 6 years since FMA first aired), I was in two minds about the whole thing. This was supposed to be a separate series, not just a sequel, so I knew the anime would have to go back over familiar ground by retelling several key stories. Considering how much groundwork there is in the first half alone, the studio would have to somehow keep the older fans interested, and yet outline these key points in the story for the newer fans as well as introducing any new plot twists from the manga. I could only see one way to do this: cram it all into as few episodes as possible. I couldn't see it working well, and I was right.
The first 14 episodes of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood are basically the result of 33 episodes of FMA crammed together. The pacing is rushed, the drawing style is too cartoony (if that makes sense) and the whole thing has a much more comedic style with random jokes thrown in everywhere. This ruins the feel of the show, somewhat reducing the effect of the more poignant moments (such as Ed and Al's fight about the 'artificial soul').
But don't give up just yet - it gets better!
From episode 15 onwards, the show slows down to a much better pace, and loses some of the unnecessary over-the-top use of comedy, although it will crop up in places. The story of the Elric brothers heads down a completely different route as new characters are introduced, and some of the regulars get more of a starring role this time around! Breda, Fuery, Falman, Havoc and Hawkeye all get upgrades from simple subordinates with some great character development, and Winry's role is looking to be grander than before.
Even the opening and closing themes are, in my opinion, better than the first anime (or Japanese music is just getting better on a whole! XD). However, none of the incidental music during the episodes quite surpasses the original series' 'Bratja'.
I recommend Brotherhood to all FMA fans. You will have to push through the first few episodes, and I don't suggest skipping as there are a few new concepts mentioned that will be of importance later on, but so far the new story has more than made up for this inconvenience. Episode 26 (the series midpoint) ended on one hell of a cliff-hanger, and even though I have to wait a while before decent subbed-versions of the next few episodes are available, Brotherhood is shaping up to be something that I'm more than happy to wait for.
Quote of the Day:
"You haven't changed, brother. You're still causing trouble!"
Alphonse Elric, FMA: Conqueror of Shamballa - Sho Aikawa
